The Best Carrot Cake Recipe In The World Ever

Jump to recipe

This is the best carrot cake recipe I’ve ever tried. It’s super moist, fluffy and light. Deliciousness next level. Made with a ton of fresh carrots, heart-healthy walnuts and a tuned down sweetness you only find in professional cake recipes.

Jump to:

• A brief history
• Why this recipe is the best
• Ingredients required
• How to make it
• How to make cream cheese frosting
• Assembling the cake
• Optional topping
• Variations
• More ideas
• Make it vegan
• Make it gluten-free
• Frequently asked questions
• Other Useful recipes
• Useful equipment for this recipe
• Best Carrot Cake Recipe in the World
• Nutrition Facts
• Comments

A brief history

Carrot cake is one of the most popular cakes in the world. In consists of the classic ingredients, we find in cake baking. Mainly flour, fat, sugar, and eggs. 

The history of carrot cake dates back to the middle ages. In Europe when sugar was a bit of a delicacy and sweet vegetables like carrots were used instead. More specifically - England. 

The first version of carrot cake was by no means the best carrot cake recipe as we know it today. It was actually a savoury dish which includes meat. 

It then slowly shifted and evolved into a meatless baked pudding.

Eventually making the rounds in France as "Gâteau de Carottes"(carrot cake) in the 19^th century as well as in Switzerland around the same time. Popularity died down. Until the English revived it during the Second World War.

Since then. It’s become a bit of a household secret and something passed around families. Jumping over the pond into America where it enjoys silly popularity. 

With a History similar to my parmesan shortbread cookies. It just shows us how interlinked our cultures and cooking habits really are.

Why this recipe is the best

If you are looking for the world’s best carrot cake recipe. You found it. It's a foolproof recipe almost anyone can cook at home.

This recipe is completely cooked from scratch which already qualifies it 50% to be the best carrot cake recipe in the World. 

The other 50% is made up of how easy it is to bake and along with a few pro tricks I learned over my 20-year cooking career. 

As well as being my favourite kind of cake when it comes to having a naughty little slice of cake. It also lends itself extremely well to other forms of itself.

Think carrot cake cupcakes, carrot cake muffins, carrot cake bunt cake or carrot cake bars.

It’s basically...An afternoon tea lovers dream.

Wherever we served this carrot cake in the 5 Star  London hotels I worked in - they were gone first. Which is why we always had tons of backup.

This recipe for carrot cake included spices which give it a luxuriously warming character. It’s perfectly fluffy and beautifully moist.

To make it extra moist we will add a touch of spiced orange liquid just after it comes out of the oven. 

You could use this trick with any cake. Think lemon cake with some lemon syrup or coffee cake with a touch of coffee syrup.

It makes perfect sense to enhance your bakery with an extra flavour boost while making the texture even more heavenly.

For best results and especially in making the best carrot cake recipe you need to use the freshest carrots. Fresh carrots are what this cake is about.

Buy the best you can afford.

Every slice should be adorned with grated sweet carrot when cooked.

Even just a "good" carrot cake should have a healthy amount of carrot evenly distributed all the way through the cake.

The best carrot cake recipe however also has some spices and roasted chopped nuts. 

To level off and level up this cake recipe we will add a lovely gingery, orangy syrup right when the cake leaves the oven. 

Let’s not forget. A Good carrot cake also needs some cream cheese frosting!

Sometimes we topped this frosting with sweet cucumber or sometimes confit carrots. 

The choices are many but the most important part is that the cream cheese frosting is enough so you get a bit with every bite.

To ensure the perfect balance we will make sure this is a layer cake.

This truly is the ultimate moist carrot cake with cream cheese frosting. It’s easy. It’s pretty quick. Straight forward and extremely difficult to mess up. 

It’s also not sickly sweet which makes it the perfect sweet treat or midnight snack. Even if you only have one sweet tooth. 

If you have a sweet tooth and love cakes try my amazing Russian honey cake recipe.

Ingredients required

You will need:

• Fat - Any oil will do. Coconut oil, vegetable or canola oil, ghee, melted butter all work best as they have less aroma. However, Olive oil does make a very interesting and unique version of this cake. This recipe uses coconut oil.
• Sugar - Brown sugar is my preference but, use white if you want or sugar replacement if you wish.
• Eggs - Large eggs. This is so that the recipe weight is correct and you don't end up messing it up by putting too little egg. Organic if possible but cake is very forgiving to egg origin. If you prefer not to use or can't find large eggs just use by the gram. Some shops even sell whole egg in cartons.
• Flour - Plain all-purpose flour or nut flours work well. Try other types like wholemeal or ancient grains
• Vanilla extract - I use it but it’s totally optional.
• Spices - Ground ginger, ground cinnamon, nutmeg. cardamom(optional), dried orange peel powder(optional)
• Baking soda and baking powder -Most good cake recipes use both.
• Salt -Always add to sweet baking a small pinch. Any salt will do. Just make sure it’s real salt.
• Vegetables and fruits -The nicest carrots you can afford. Carrot cake after all no. Orange(optional), fresh ginger(optional)
• Nuts -I used walnuts but, go for pecan or hazelnuts as the next best. Any nut will do.
• Dairy -Cream cheese and butter for the frosting although you could leave out the butter with no adverse effect.
• Sour cream if you are using my exact recipe. Otherwise, you could sub it with any fruit or vegetable puree like apple sauce or carrot puree. Also, go with yoghurt or really thick cream if you wish.

How to make it

1^st step - Line your baking pans with oiled greaseproof baking paper. I usually oil the pan and the paper. Try it and you will see the method in my madness.

Heat the oven to 170C. 

2^nd Step - Make the cake batter. Sieve the dry ingredients. Roast cool and roughly clean the walnuts. Then chop them up roughly. Mix together the fat, sugar, eggs, vanilla, and grated carrots. Mix everything up with a spoon until you have a homogenous cake mix.

3^rd Step – Pour your cake batter into the lined baking tin or round cake pan if you wish. Bake for 30 minutes. Check the temperature with a temperature probe. 

While the cake is cooking. Make the cake topping. Place all the ingredient for the topping into a small pan and lightly simmer until the carrot is soft and the water has almost all evaporated. 

In another pan, place the juice of one orange, zest of the same orange, 150g water and 20g sugar together.

Warm-up and keep to the side until the cake comes out of the oven. You then drizzle this syrup all over the cake while still hot.

It should read above 90C. Or until a wooden skewer or toothpick inserted in the middle of the cakes comes out clean. This is ancient so I urge you to buy a thermometer. They only cost about 3 dollars.  

As soon as the cake is done poke a few holes with a tooth pick and drizzle the orange liquid all over it.

Remove the cake from the pan/tin and let them cool on a wire baking rack until completely cooled down.

4^th Step – While the cake is chilling out and cooling off. Make the frosting by sifting the icing sugar and mixing with room temperature cream cheese and butter.

How to make cream cheese frosting

This cream cheese frosting recipe can be made by hand using a whisk and mixing bowl or in a stand mixer. 

Make sure that both your cream cheese and butter are at room temperature. Sift the powdered sugar to make sure there are no lumps and it comes out silky smooth. We all like silky smooth.

To make the cream cheese frosting, simply stir the cream cheese and butter together with the vanilla until completely smooth.  Then add in the sifted powdered sugar. 

Mixy-mixy and you have a tangy sweet and velvety smooth cream cheese frosting. 

**Note

Never use low-fat cream cheese because it will result in a runny frosting. 

If you need a touch more powdered sugar go ahead and add some. I have made the cake part of this recipe not too sweet so that it can handle a sweet frosting and the orange syrup.

Assembling the cake

Once the cake reaches room temperature, cut it in half horizontally. You could cut off the sides and level the top if you want. I usually just do that to have a little nibble and then end up with little snacky bits.

Place the first cake on serving platter or wooden board, add a large spoon full of frosting to the first layer.

Place the other half on top and top up with more cream cheese frosting. follow by sprinkling some toasted chopped nuts and carrot confit.

The best carrot cake, bon Appetit!

** Pro tip - Place the cake halves in the fridge or freezer for 20 minutes before icing to ensure they are properly chilled. This ensures no melty frosting problems.

Optional topping

This part is optional as not all carrot cakes have a topping. I prefer it though as it separates the amateur recipe from the best carrot cake recipe even further. 

When your cake is frosted just add a bit of the confit carrot and a few chopped roasted walnuts. You could easily substitute the confit with store-bought orange or carrot marmalade or the walnuts with pecans or any other nut you fancy.

Variations

You can easily modify this cake by doing the following:

• Other nuts - Pecan nuts, hazelnuts, pistachios and almonds or a mix of these can be added instead of walnuts - Roast and crush some extra for the carrot cake topping.
• Dried fruit - Think dried apricots, raisins, sultanas, dates, dried prunes. Chop up some and add to the carrot cake mix.
• Like coconut? Add some toasted coconut powder or chopped up flakes or replace half the sour cream with coconut cream.
• Carrot cake spices – Up the spices already in this recipe. Add some like star anise, cardamom or dried ground orange peel. 
• Carrot cake with apple sauce – Replace the sour cream with apple sauce, carrot puree or pear puree. Any will do.
• Cake made with nut flour – Replace the normal flour with almond flour or do half almond half all-purpose flour.
• Carrot cake frosting – Make a dairy-free frosting by bringing to the boil 400g coconut milk, 50g sugar, 100g water and 6g agar-agar while whisking. Set in the fridge and blend to a smooth gel when cooled down. Spice up a classic cream cheese frosting by adding some ground cinnamon and ginger powder.
• Fresh fruit – For a carrot cake with pineapple add some tinned pineapple pieces into the mix. Just coat in a bit of flour first.
• Upside down pineapple carrot cake – Lay some pineapple pieces on the bottom of the baking tin or tray. Pour and bake the mix on top of pineapples and flip upside-down when done.

More ideas

• Cupcakes - Use this recipe to make cupcakes. Just bake in cupcake forms.
• Carrot bread  - Remove the icing/frosting and reduce the sugar to 50g. Bake as instructed and you have a carrot cake bread.
• Carrot loaf – Bake this mix in a loaf pan or bread tin. The frosting is optional.
• Overnight oats  - Soak oats as normal with coconut milk, water, juice or mix of these. When done crumble up some carrot cake and stir trough or sprinkle on top.
• Ice cream – Make fresh vanilla or yoghurt ice cream and stir in some crumbled up carrot cake. For a cheat ice cream use store-bought vanilla ice cream and stir some broken up carrot cake through it.
• Muffins – Same as for carrot cake cupcakes. Just top with some muffin streusel and bake in muffin forms.
• Trifle – Replace the usual sponge cake with carrot cake. Use in alternate layers to layer your carrot cake trifle.
• Smoothie - Make a smoothy by blending up with almond milk or orange juice with a pinch of cinnamon or ginger and zesting of orange rind. It's good. Try it.
• With orange – This recipe includes orange rind and juice in the syrup. You could boil an orange in some sugary water until completely tender. Blend it up and use instead of the sour cream. Add orange zest to the mix and also some confit orange rind or marmalade as a topping.
• Cheesecake – Use up some old carrot cake by mixing up with classic vanilla cheesecake recipe and baking at 90C for 2 hours or until just set. Soak some more carrot cake with orange or carrot syrup or even a touch of Cointreau. Use as a topping for cheesecake.

Make it vegan

By replacing the following:

• Replace the egg with 30g linseeds(flaxseed flour) soaked in 60g water for 30 minutes.
• Add 150g coconut milk
• Use vegan cream cheese instead of dairy cream cheese.
• Use vegan butter instead of dairy butter.

Make it gluten-free

By replacing the following:

• Regular flour for almond flour or any other nut flour.
• Gluten-free baking powder for regular baking powder

Frequently asked questions

Other Useful recipes

If you like baking cakes or bread you will love the following recipes:

• Spiced apple cake
• Cherry and almond tart
• Russian honey cake
• Borodinsky dark rye bread
• Wholewheat flax sourdough bread
• Parmesan biscuits

Useful equipment for this recipe

Rectangle Cake Pan – Buy Now

THIS PAGE CONTAINS AFFILIATE LINKS - I MIGHT EARN A TINY % OF THE SALE THROUGH THESE LINKS AT NO EXTRA COST TO YOU. PROBABLY NOT EVEN ENOUGH TO BUY A BEER).

If you found this recipe helpful or have learned something, comment, subscribe and follow me on social platforms for more delicious recipes.