If you wanted to know how to make the best homemade Caesar dressing you came to the right place. This recipe is mainly traditional but uses smart modern methods to take it to the next level.
- Interesting facts
- Why this recipe is special
- Ingredients needed
- How to make roasted garlic
- How to make it
- How to fix a split or broken emulsion?
- Advanced tip
- Serving suggestions
- Frequently asked questions
- Other recipes you might like
- Useful equipment for this recipe
- Homemade Caesar dressing
- Nutrition Facts
Although Caesar dressing is mainly used in Caesar salad, it is also a great back-pocket recipe that you can easily and quickly whisk up for a wide variety of other salads and snacks.
I have seen many different Caesar dressing recipes in my time. Some include parmesan, soy sauce, tabasco and even orange juice.
These variations might be tasty but it's not a traditional Caesar dressing that honour the original recipe.
I have personally made many imitations but, there is ultimately only one way to make it.
What's Caesar dressing and how should it taste like?
A classic Caesar dressing should be creamy but not heavy and unbalanced. It should have punchy umami taste, zingy freshness and well-rounded saltiness. No single ingredient should dominate.
The caesar dressing ingredients should all work together to create a wonderful bit of harmony you can drizzle all over Caesar salad or dip freshly cut crispy vegetables into.
Traditionally Caesar dressing was whisked up tableside. It's origin dates back to 4th July 1924.
Caesar salad was invented out of necessity by Caesar Cardini.
The Italian immigrant restauranteur who had to throw together something for hungry guests on Independence day as his restaurant Caesar's was overwhelmed by guests and he ran out of food.
Although the original recipe did not contain anchovies it did have a rich fermented anchovy flavour it got from the Worchester sauce. One of the key ingredients in Worchester sauce is anchovies.
Earlier versions had a punchier taste and used more anchovies which contributed to the rich flavour.
Nowadays the flavour of anchovies are not so predominant so we add a bit of anchovy to make up for the loss.
This is an optional step in the recipe but I highly recommend you add it.
Why this recipe is special
By tweaking a small part of the recipe we can make this dressing stand out from the crowd.
Our secret little trick is using roasted garlic instead of raw. It transforms this recipe from great to fantastic.
We also use a mix of olive oil and neutral oil to make sure the dressing is not bitter.
Ingredients for Caesar dressing are very few and easy to find. For this reason, buy the best you can afford.
- Eggs - You will only need the yolks and if you are afraid of a raw egg then use pasteurised egg yolk. Easily found in many stores.
- Dijon mustard - Use a smooth no grainy version.
- Worchestershire sauce - Lee & Perrins is a good brand.
- Lemon - Nice and fresh.
- Garlic - The freshest young garlic. Although, Roasting Chinese garlic is ok.
- Anchovy fillets(optional) - Sold in most stores. Alternatively, use anchovy paste.
- Olive oil - Use a good extra virgin that's not too bitter.
- Neutral oil - Canola, sunflower or groundnut oil. Anything with a neutral taste. Stay away from hydrogenated oils.
You might realise there is no Parmesan in the list above. That's because real Caesar dressing does not contain Parmesan cheese.
The salad however does.
How to make roasted garlic
Using roasted garlic is optional. However, It is the secret ingredient that sets our Caesar dressing recipe apart from any other recipe you might have come across.
It adds an amazing depth of flavour, smoothness and richness to the dressing.
We use roasted garlic instead of raw garlic because the taste compliments the rest of the flavours instead of fighting against it and we end up with a much smoother creamy Caesar dressing.
Bonus Reason. No garlic breath)
How to make it
Which order you add ingredients to Caesar dressing is very important. It's an emulsion sauce. Which means that we need to whisk oil into a water base. Essentially making a mayonnaise.
This can be done either by hand, in a high-speed jug blender or with a hand-held mixer and whisk attachment.
- Combine all the ingredients apart from the oils in a mixing bowl or jug blender.
- Blend or whisk until combined and smooth.
- Slowly whisk or blend in the oils until fully emulsified.
- Adjust the seasoning if you want.
- Store in the fridge or use straight away.
How to fix a split or broken emulsion?
You might end up splitting the dressing if you add the oil too quickly.
Not to worry. We can easily fix this.
- Wait for the oil to separate a bit more and pour or scoop of this oil layer placing in a container. We will add it back in in a minute.
- Add a teaspoon of cold water to a bowl or blender.
- While whisking/blending vigorously, add the base part to the water.
- Continue adding the oil back in.
- You emulsion should now be stable again.
You can follow me on Instagram @PANTSDWONAPRONSON and ask me any question by directly messaging me.
I am helping many people with a wide variety of question about food and other cooking-related questions.
This way I have helped many people become better and more confident cooks.
- If you are pressed for time you can skip the baked garlic and use fresh minced garlic. Use ¼th of the measure in the recipe as it will be too strong otherwise.
- Caesar dressing without anchovies? No problem just remove from the recipe.
- You could use ready mayonnaise instead of making your own emulsion. Replace the oil part with mayonnaise and whisk in as usual.
- You could make a vegan version by using vegan mayonnaise, removing the anchovies and Worchester sauce and replacing with a vegan alternative.
Caesar dressing is already Keto so no need to adjust anything unless you are vegan and Keto and your mayonnaise are loaded with carbs. In That case, proceed by making your own emulsion.
If you make your own garum from fish or squid. Use that in combination with Worchester sauce. For the restaurant version of this dressing, I use a 50-50 split of homemade Worchester sauce and high temperature aged squid garum.
If you are a professional or very ambitious home cook then get in contact and I will explain step by step how to do this.
Apart from using this dressing in authentic Caesar salad You could use it as a dip for Crudités or pour over any other salad or vegetable dish.
- Use instead of a similar dressing in Salmon and egg salad.
- Bacon and potato salad - Use instead of the honey mustard.
- Roasted carrots with chanterelles - Drizzle over these carrots when cooled down a bit.
- Coleslaw - Use instead of the dressing for coleslaw for a completely different coleslaw experience.
- Dip sourdough bread into this dressing for a no-fuss snack.
- Pour over these roasted Romano peppers.
- Great with steamed vegetables like broccoli, spinach or bok choy.
- Even with roasted meats and fish like this pan-seared salmon fillet. This fire-roasted pork belly braai, or these lamb chops.
Frequently asked questions
How long does it keep?
1 week if you store it correctly and made it with pasteurised egg or mayonnaise.
How to store this dressing?
Once made, store in airtight containers or bottles in the fridge.
Can I freeze it?
No, emulsions split when frozen. So you would have to follow the fix mentioned above to bring it back together. Better eaten straight away.
Is caesar dressing gluten and dairy-free?
It's dairy-free but not gluten-free. There might be trace amounts of gluten in the mustard and Worchestershire sauce. You can easily buy gluten-free alternatives though.
Can I make this recipe without egg?
You can but, it's not as good. Egg provides richness, creaminess and helps the dressing emulsify. If not using egg you would need to use a bit more mustard to help emulsify the oil.
If you are familiar with lecthin you could also add ¼ spoon full to the liquid part of this recipe before adding the oils. Lecithin is a surfactant. meaning it binds to oil and water.
It's natural and found in health food stores.
Is caesar dressing healthy?
A bit over a healthy salad will not hurt anyone. It's loaded with fat though so if you are following a low-fat diet then eat in moderation.
Other recipes you might like
If you like making homemade versions of recipes you will love the following.
- Lemonade - Triple citrus homemade lemonade or it's strawberry lemonade cousin.
- Bread - This homemade flaxseed sourdough is super fluffy and easy to bake.
- Something sweet - My favourite honey cake, seasonal cherry tart or the best ever carrot and walnut cake with cream cheese frosting.
- Sriracha - Ferment your own Sriracha hot sauce at home.
- Pasta - always better when homemade. This 2-ingredient no-knead pasta and this easy tomato pasta dish to cook with it.
- Salmon gravlax - Homemade cured salmon gravlax used in this salmon salad or great on some toasted Borodinsky bread.
- Chimichurri - Poor this delicious chimichurri sauce recipe all over a pan-fried steak, roasted broccoli or even use as a salad dressing.
Useful equipment for this recipe
High-speed blender - Buy Now
Mixing bowl - Buy Now
Hand-held blender - Buy Now
Whisk - Buy Now
THIS PAGE CONTAINS AFFILIATE LINKS - I MIGHT EARN A TINY % OF THE SALE THROUGH THESE LINKS NO EXTRA COST TO YOU. PROBABLY NOT EVEN ENOUGH TO BUY A BEER).
If you found this post helpful or have learned something, comment, subscribe and follow me on social platforms for more tasty recipes.
DID YOU MAKE THIS RECIPE?
Tag @PANTSDWONAPRONSON on Instagram and hashtag it #PANTSDOWNAPRONSON